
photo credit: Russ Melton / BloodHorse
The Big Brown Belmont loss controversy has heated up again in the last week,
after pictures surfaced showing his shoe partially off right at the break of the Belmont, and another taken right as Desormeaux was pulling him up near the finish line.
Basically what that means is that for some reason, Brown's shoe dislodged at or near the start (which some had thought anyway) but stayed dislodged throughout the race. As you can see below, the nail is protruding and the shoe is partially off.

photo credit: Bob Mayberger / BloodHorse
Obviously that could not have been comfortable- and, feeling something odd, Brown knew it and couldn't get himself into the race due to the awkwardness of the shoe problem.
There is also some feeling that another horse - Guadalcanal - stepped on Brown's right hind foot as they sprung forward from the gate.
Add to that the thought that the official starter at the gate was standing in an unusual place (right on the track basically in front of the field as they broke) when the race began, and you have got all the controversy and explanation that you would need for Big Brown's dismal performance.
It is obvious, to me, that the racing gods didn't like the way Big Brown's name looked right under Affirmed on the Triple Crown winners list, and this was their way of saying 'no can do'.
Big Brown is next scheduled (as of now) to run in the million dollar Haskell Invitational at the beginning of August at Monmouth Park in New Jersey - so I guess we'll see if he can bounce back and if he is truly the outstanding colt most people feel he is.
His trainer (busted this week and serving a suspension for illegal drugs found in one of his horses) is still a stellar jackass. But don't hold that against the horse.
Brown wants to show you that he is still on top. That his name is still worthy of being mentioned in the same breath as Seattle Slew or Secretariat.
Well, he's got his work cut out for him.
And a big hurdle on his way to Horse of the Year honors is spelled C-U-R-L-I-N.
Brownie's got to beat the big guns to claim any fame. Don't know if that will happen, as Curlin isn't running in the Haskell that I know of, and I don't think they are even planning on running him in the Breeders' Cup Classic due to it being on artificial surface at Santa Anita. Guess we'll wait and see.
If Curlin wins if they travel to France for the Prix de l’Arc de Triomphe (Fr-I), and Brown wins the Haskell and the Classic - the Horse of the Year race will be a tough one indeed.
It's been a good year for racing, despite all the negative happenings, controversies, and bad luck.
The horses still rock.